Used cooking oil: one feedstock, different renewable fuels – a comparative study

For: EWABA (European Waste-to-Advanced Biofuels Association) and MVaK (German Mittelstandsverband abfallbasierter Kraftstoffe)

[November 2020 – February 2021]

studio Gear Up analysed for EWABA and MVaK the techno-economic and greenhouse gas emission impacts of four biofuel pathways based on used cooking oil (UCO). Many members of EWABA and MVaK use UCO as their main feedstock. UCO is a waste-based vegetable oil, collected from food manufacturers, restaurants, catering facilities and kitchens in schools, hospitals or households. It is used to produce several types of renewable and sustainable fuels, through different pathways. EWABA and MVaK wanted to understand how the four main current pathways perform in terms of several economic and environmental impacts.

studio Gear Up assessed the benefits of four renewable fuel pathways that use UCO as a feedstock:

  • UCOME (known as “biodiesel”),
  • UCO-HVO (“renewable diesel”),
  • UCO co-processed with fossil oil, and
  • UCO-HEFA (a “Sustainable Aviation Fuel”).

The assessment involves detailed techno-economic analyses on basis of industry data and literature.

Results

The production and application of UCOME in road transport provides the highest carbon savings against the lowest costs, due to the relatively simple process technology and high feedstock efficiency, the study shows. And since the UCOME conversion installations already exist, these savings can be achieved without additional investments. On the other hand, application of UCO in HEFA for aviation is costly.

This insight is important for policy makers who currently prefer to deploy UCO in aviation where it achieves considerably less climate savings per given tonne of UCO. At the same time, UCOME producers should understand that over time electrification will reduce the need for renewable fuels in the road sector. Policy makers and industry should understand which UCO pathway is performing best at each moment in time, to optimise climate emission reduction.

The complete report is found here.

Related

High blends of renewable fuels for the heavy-duty fleet in the Netherlands

KiM Netherlands Institute for Transport Policy Analysis (Kennisinstituut voor Mobiliteit – KiM) commissioned studio Gear Up to conduct research to explore the options for high-blends of renewable fuels in the heavy-duty fleet. This research served as input for KiM’s (2025) report: Renewable fuels in high blends in road freight transport , which provides recommendations for Dutch policy makers aiming to shape climate action in the road sector. The study sets out to explore alternative fuel options available to heavy-duty vehicles given that there is “uncertainty about the pace of truck electrification”. 

Read More

sGU recommendations for practical certification guidelines intermediate crops

Intermediate crops are crops planted and harvested between main crops in a crop rotation scheme. Their development, on top of existing food and feed farm output, offer additional volumes of feedstocks for the bioeconomy without requiring additional land. studio Gear Up assessed the benefits of intermediate crops, the bottlenecks for their development and deployment and provided recommendations for certification of these crops in the frame of the Renewable Energy Directive.

Read More

Consequences of ETS2 implementation on A-B-C deliveries of renewable fuels

Our research for the Ministry of Infrastructure and Water Management shows that the introduction of the new ETS2 emissions trading system can have important consequences for these constructions. Because these A-B-C supply constructions play a major role in the Dutch fuel market, this is expected to make the use of A-B-C supplies less attractive for fuel suppliers, with market shift and concentration likely to result. 

Read More
Scroll to Top